Short answer: Oral citrulline raised blood arginine more than arginine did in a 20-person head-to-head study, because more citrulline is absorbed from the gut.12 For workouts, NIH says the research is limited and conflicting for both and does not strongly support either.2
| Citrulline | Arginine | |
|---|---|---|
| How it relates | About 80% is turned into arginine in the kidneys2 | Used to make nitric oxide and creatine2 |
| Gut absorption | More absorbed than arginine2 | Much is broken down in the gut before it reaches the blood1 |
| Blood arginine (head to head) | Raised it more than arginine did1 | Raised it less1 |
| Exercise evidence (NIH) | Few trials, conflicting2 | Little to no effect at 2 to 20 g a day2 |
| Amounts in studies | 8 g citrulline malate 1 hour before exercise; up to 6 g a day for 4 weeks2 | Mostly 2 to 10 g as a single dose2 |
| Side effects | Stomach discomfort in 6 of 41 weightlifters2 | 9 to 30 g a day: diarrhea, nausea, slight drop in blood pressure2 |
In a randomized crossover study of 20 healthy volunteers, a week of oral citrulline raised blood arginine levels more than the same approach with arginine, and the highest citrulline amount (3 g twice a day) improved markers of nitric oxide signaling. No treatment improved blood-vessel widening (FMD) over baseline.1 In another study, single doses of 2 to 15 g of citrulline caused no side effects, but at the highest doses arginine rose less than expected.3
Arginine: NIH says 2 to 20 g a day had little to no effect on performance, usually did not raise nitric oxide or blood flow in trained athletes, and a review of 54 studies found little or no benefit.2
Citrulline: in one trial, 8 g of citrulline malate allowed more bench-press repetitions; in another, citrulline without malate led to worse treadmill performance than placebo. NIH concludes the research does not strongly support it. Citrulline malate is 56.64% citrulline by weight.2
These are study protocols, not personalized advice; confirm any dosing with your prescriber. More detail: Beetroot juice vs citrulline: which pre-workout has better evidence?, and the L-Citrulline and L-Arginine guides.