Short answer: No, according to CDC. It says people with the common MTHFR variants can process all types of folate, including folic acid, and that these variants are not a reason to avoid it. People with two copies of the C677T variant have about 16% lower blood folate on the same intake, but 400 mcg a day still raises folate levels. Folic acid is the only form of folate shown to prevent neural tube defects.
MTHFR is a gene for an enzyme that helps the body turn folate into its active form, 5-methyltetrahydrofolate (5-MTHF). Everyone has two copies of the gene. The most common variant is C677T; another is A1298C. CDC says more people in the US have one or two copies of C677T than do not, and that it is more common in Hispanic people.
The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements (ODS) says people with two copies of C677T have a reduced ability to make 5-MTHF, which can raise homocysteine and the risk of neural tube defects (NTDs). ODS gives these rates of two-copy C677T: about 25% of Hispanic people, 10% of white and Asian people and 1% of Black Americans.
CDC calls the idea that people with a variant should avoid folic acid and use 5-MTHF instead "not true", and says folic acid is the only type of folate shown to help prevent NTDs. ODS agrees that CDC recommends 400 mcg a day of folic acid, not 5-MTHF, even with the C677T variant.
ODS says the evidence on extra benefit for people with the variant is inconclusive and that some might benefit from 5-MTHF. It also notes the body absorbs 5-MTHF in supplements as well as or better than folic acid. What has not been shown is that 5-MTHF prevents NTDs, because the trials that proved prevention used folic acid. CDC also points out that rare MTHFR variants, unlike the common ones, can have real health effects and are worth raising with a doctor or genetic counselor.
The CDC advice is the same with or without a variant: 400 mcg of folic acid a day, starting at least a month before conception (see when to start folic acid). A doctor may suggest more for other health conditions. Dose Track can keep the prenatal vitamin on a daily reminder, next to any fertility medicines.
Read more on Dose Track: Folate · Female fertility · PCOS · Dietary supplement